In this first post of the New Year, Dr Susan Clarke, in her role as module co-ordinator considers the value of reflection.
I’ve been enjoying the Friday ritual of reading Maggie and Iain’s Connected Learning blog so thought I might share some of my thoughts on the importance of reflection- not the students’ reflection, but our own reflective practice as educators, and specifically as module coordinators.
A record of real time feelings
Most of you know that I was one of, and am now solely, the module co-ordinator for EBN2. Most years, I keep a reflective diary on my experiences through the module. I do this for several reasons, primarily because my memory is really bad and I want to make sure when we come to run the module for the next intake that I know which bits need tweaked but also because it is a record of my real time feelings and reflections. We all internalise this, right? So I’m just putting my thoughts to paper.
Justifying the need for action
I don’t write reams of text and it mostly consists of bullet points, but I write notes to myself of what worked and what didn’t work and why that might be. The why is very important and I don’t think you remember that if you don’t write it as you experience it. Another important aspect is the action points- suggestions for what I can change that will address the problem. Again, too easy to ignore these suggestions if I haven’t made a note to myself of the “why” to justify the need for action. We are all busy and have competing priorities in this incredibly varied job we do so we could be forgiven for not instigating change if we didn’t need to!
This year, more than most, with the new curriculum, the move to online/remote delivery and the fact that EBN2 is now totally delivered in one teaching phase (will I even remember what a PICO is by the time it rolls around again never mind the nuances of timing the delivery of key messages?!), my ritual has been invaluable. Just a few moments at the end of each week to write my reflections meant that, when we had our debriefing meeting at the end of the module, I was able to identify key learning points for our team and to make suggestions for modifications when delivering it to the February cohort.
Another tool to maximise our teaching practice
This is an entirely new curriculum. We expect too much of it and ourselves if we think it will work perfectly straight out of the box so, dare I say it, evidence based modifications for future cohorts are not only necessary but essential to make it work as well as it can. We teach the students action cycles of plan, do, study, act and that can equally be applied to our education setting as to their healthcare practice. Combining our personal reflections with student feedback, external examiner feedback and team debriefings means we have a well-rounded view of our modules and is just one more tool in our armoury to maximise our teaching practice.
Excellent. Thanks for this very thoughtful piece Susan!
Susan, thank you, for reminding me of the importance of committing those real time post class feelings to paper! Hopefully a cathartic New Years resolution I will keep and act on going forward.
Couldn’t agree more – teaching is iterative and Both the content and delivery improves with age, like our good selves 😉 It is good to be reminded how important it is to commit the thoughts to paper.
Thanks Susan.
I have used this in the past also thanks Susan for the reminder. It is interesting to look back on those reflections which include not just the negative but also the positive and what worked well.
Hi Susan,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. As Patricia Benner would suggest, reflection and reflective practice, moves us from knowledge to expert. I do some of my reflection on my daily run, a time for myself and further learning. I am not sure that students realise just how much we learn from them.
Thanks Susan – very practical and helpful. Also some good ideas to assist colleagues who need to revalidate with the NMC for example as it is hard to recall last week let along 2 or 3 years ago and the feedback received and what we did with it. Also good for colleagues thinking about SFHEA and PFHEA applications where impact and outcome evidence is key. Thanks once again!
This is a really useful tip Susan. Thank you for sharing your experiences of this practice and how you have utilised the ritual to the benefit of the module – and yourself. I am going to give it a go – thanks!